메뉴 건너뛰기

XEDITION

Board

id="article-body" class="row" section="article-body" data-component="trackCWV">


















Squid Game is a sensation.


Netflix


Safe to say a whole lot of people are watching Squid Game. The South Korean dark survival drama is Netflix's most successful non-English language show. According to Netflix boss Ted Sarandos, the horror featuring deadly children's games is on its way to overtaking Bridgerton as Netflix's biggest show ever.

Here's the sting. Some viewers have noticed significant differences in the Korean-to-English translations. Depending on your Netflix settings, your English subtitles might lose something in the translation, to the point of being downright "bad" and changing the show's meaning, according to one viewer.






So what settings should you use? Let's dive into it all below.

Change this subtitle setting


Netflix/CNET screenshot

In a nutshell, if you want "substantially better" English subtitles, use the setting, "English."

The other English language option is "English [CC]," which many have pointed out doesn't provide a nuanced translation.

What's the difference?

English Closed Captions subtitles are specifically intended for those who are deaf and hard of hearing. "Captions not only display words as the textual equivalent of spoken dialogue or narration, but they also include speaker identification, sound effects, and music description," according to the National Association of the Deaf.

Basically, the difference between English and English [CC] is that the closed-captions setting provides descriptions of sounds, such as gasps, and prompts as to who is speaking. They're often autogenerated and, in Squid Game's case according to one viewer, a closer match to the English dub than the English subtitles.

Lost in translation: 'the character's purpose'

Squid Game is centered on a contest where 456 desperate players from different social classes compete for a life-changing 45.6 billion won prize.

A viral thread on Twitter dove into how the closed-captions translation went as far as changing the meaning of the show. Youngmi Mayer, who co-hosts the Feeling Asian podcast, wrote last week, "not to sound snobby but i'm fluent in korean and i watched squid game with english subtitles and if you don't understand korean you didn't really watch the same show. translation was so bad. the dialogue was written so well and zero of it was preserved."


















window.CnetFunctions.logWithLabel('%c One Trust ', "Service loaded: script_twitterwidget with class optanon-category-5");




Mayer presented a scene breakdown on TikTok to illustrate some of the lost meanings.

In one scene, the character Han Mi-nyeo, a woman who claims to be a poor single mother, tries to convince people to play the game terbaru with her. The closed-captions translation says, "I'm not a genius, but I still got it work out. Huh?"

Mayer says the correct translation is: "I am very smart. I just never got a chance to study."

Mayer added, "That is a huge trope in Korean media. The poor person that's smart and clever and just isn't wealthy. That's a huge part of her character. And almost everything she says is being botched, translation-wise... The writers, all they want you to know about her is that... [It] seems so small, but it's the entire character's purpose of being in the show."


















window.CnetFunctions.logWithLabel('%c One Trust ', "Service loaded: script_twitterwidget with class optanon-category-5");




'Wildly different'

In response, one Twitter user provided Netflix's English subtitles, which differ to the closed captions.

"You have to change your Netflix settings to English not English CC. Here is a screen grab of that scene with English. (Screen is black cause they don't allow grabs but the subtitle comes through)," wrote @ADeVonJohnson.


















window.CnetFunctions.logWithLabel('%c One Trust ', "Service loaded: script_twitterwidget with class optanon-category-5");




Another Twitter user found that the closed-captions translation matched the English dub.

"I found you got different subtitles depending if you chose English or English Closed Caption (with the latter matching the dubbed dialogue and the former being wildly different)," wrote @MrTimCat.


















window.CnetFunctions.logWithLabel('%c One Trust ', "Service loaded: script_twitterwidget with class optanon-category-5");




Mayer has reportedly since clarified that the English language subtitles are "substantially better" than the closed-captions ones.

Although, Mayer added, "The misses in the metaphors -- and what the writers were trying to actually say -- are still pretty present."

Netflix didn't immediately respond to a request for comment.

번호 제목 글쓴이 날짜 조회 수
12569 Perfect For A High School Tryout! JenniferFosbrook 2021.10.20 1
12568 Judi Slots Online Indonesia Hebat Dan Beri Keuntungan CathernFeng220903 2021.10.20 2
12567 Halti No Pull Harness Secrets And Techniques RosaTni816147563 2021.10.20 3
12566 Inchirieri Auto Timisoara - Bavaria Mobility (2) FelipaCallister5053 2021.10.20 1
12565 Nyatanya Berikut Ini Situs Judi Online Yang Memberi Keuntungan Chastity42825769509 2021.10.20 1
12564 Teknik Menang Main Slots Online Paling Gampang ArnoldMkb071293328441 2021.10.20 1
12563 Bonus Sbobet EGOStephen931743 2021.10.20 1
12562 Cool Little Fast Shipping Dropshipping Device OlgaTrudeau93730698 2021.10.20 2
12561 Judi Slot MagdalenaMcinnis 2021.10.20 1
12560 Pedoman Unggul Cepat Di Permainan Slots Online Classic NormanVenn299774813 2021.10.20 2
12559 Kehebohan Permainan Judi Kasino Online BryceJacques755246 2021.10.20 3
12558 وکیل تهران: وکالت دعاوی , مشاوره حقوقی و مشاوره خانواده VelmaSze95240651 2021.10.20 2
12557 Man Who Launched Family-run Sex Toy Business Says It's 'never Awkward' BreannaW55942885742 2021.10.20 2
12556 Harmful Goods Drivers And Automobiles ThurmanTew65769719 2021.10.20 2
12555 Как Выбрать Сервисный Центр StephaineBunch398 2021.10.20 1
12554 The Very Best Multilevel Marketing Opportunity: How Wildly Well Known Do You Believe On The Internet Video Games Are? ZZXCelesta4320830207 2021.10.19 1
12553 Akses Taruhan Judi Online Lewat Smartpone ElenaWant101810634 2021.10.19 4
12552 24 Hrs Internet Betting Webinternet web site Along with Adequate Company MonteKolb495603 2021.10.19 2
12551 คู่มือฉบับย่อเพื่อดูหนังออนไลน์ IODAugust2004183 2021.10.19 4
12550 Benefits Of Workplace Coffee Machines BobbieMortimer703197 2021.10.19 3
위로